Feature comparison
Critique
Google's much beloved internal code review tool.
Review Dashboard
- Review Dashboard
Dashboard showcasing all pull requests your involved in.
- Yes
- Attention Set
List of pull requests currently waiting on you.
- Yes
- Who's Turn to Act
Showcases who a pull request is waiting on.
- Yes
- Pull Requests Go Green
When pull requests reached an approved state, the status turns green and you rejoice.
- Yes
- Time Estimates
View estimates for how long a review should take and plan your schedule accordingly.
- Snooze
Snooze pull requests you want to tackle later to keep your inbox actionable.
- Remaining Items
Quickly see a breakdown of the work you have remaining (discussions, files, and lines of code to review) for each pull request.
Reviews
- Pre-Review Tools
Assists in polishing changes before review, showing diffs, build and test results, and style checks.
- Yes
- Turn Tracking
Track who needs to take the next action on a pull request.
- Yes
- Notifications
Companion Chrome extension that notifies you when your action is needed and see your review queue.
- Yes
- Merge Functionality
Changes are submitted and committed within Critique itself.
- Yes
- Keyboard Shortcuts
Navigation speed via amazing keyboard shortcuts.
- Yes
- Comment History Table
View analysis and history and comments of the PR in a tabular format that makes it much easier to understand the progress of a PR with multiple rounds of code
- Yes
- IDE Integration
Integration with code editors.
- Yes
- Issue Tracker Integration
Integration with issue/bug tracking software.
- Yes
- Linkification of Code & Comments
Auto linkification of both code and comments.
- Yes
- Anonymized Reviews
Code reviews can also be anonymized, where the code author can be kept anonymous from the reviewer.
- Yes
Diffs
- Revision History
Snapshots code when reviews are submitted and allow comparison between any two revisions.
- Yes
- Diff from Last Review
Pick up where you left off and only view changes since you last reviewed the files.
- Yes
- Side by Side Diff
Ability to compare two versions of a file side-by-side.
- Yes
- Unified Diff
Ability to compare two versions of a file in a single pane.
- Syntax Highlighting
Diffing enhanced with syntax highlighting
- Yes
- Intraline Diffing
Highlight partial changes to an individual line of code.
- Yes
- Ignores Whitespace
Ignore whitespace changes to simplify the diff.
- Yes
- Cross References
- Yes
- Move Detection
Detect code that moved to simplify the review process.
- Yes
Comments
- Blocking & Non-Blocking Comments
Identify blocking issues that prevent pull request merging until resolved, or provide informational feedback and suggestions.
- Yes
- Comment Anywhere
Comment on any file and any line, with no restrictions.
- Yes
- Context Maintained
Comments intelligently maintain context/position as code evolves, ensuring they are always relevant.
- Yes
- Anyone Can Comment
Anyone can comment on a change and there are features to track review progress and resolve comments.
- Yes
- "Please Fix"
Reviewers have the option to click “Please fix” on an analysis generated comment as a signal that the author should fix the issue.
- Yes
- Consistent Terminology
Social adoption of consistent terminology/tagging of comments (eg: optional, fyi, nit, etc.)
- Yes
- Discussion Resolution Flow
Guide individual discussions to a satisfactory resolution, verified by all necessary participants.
- Discussion Assignment
Assign discussions to the responsible participant to ensure accountability.
Other
- AI Tools
Helpful AI tools to aid your code review process.
- Yes
- GitHub Integration
Full two-way data sync'ing of pull requests, reviews, comments, reactions and more.
- Live Team Status
See who's online and what pull requests your teammates are currently working on.
- Elegant Design
We labor over the UX so you don’t have to. CodePeer helps you get stuff done and gets out of the way.
- Light and Dark Mode
Choose between light and dark mode to manage your eye strain.
- Ridiculously Fast
Heavily optimized for performance, because milliseconds matter.
CodePeer
A modern approach to code reviews for forward-thinking teams.
Review Dashboard
- Review Dashboard
Dashboard showcasing all pull requests your involved in.
- Yes
- Attention Set
List of pull requests currently waiting on you.
- Yes
- Who's Turn to Act
Showcases who a pull request is waiting on.
- Yes
- Pull Requests Go Green
When pull requests reached an approved state, the status turns green and you rejoice.
- Yes
- Time Estimates
View estimates for how long a review should take and plan your schedule accordingly.
- Yes
- Snooze
Snooze pull requests you want to tackle later to keep your inbox actionable.
- Yes
- Remaining Items
Quickly see a breakdown of the work you have remaining (discussions, files, and lines of code to review) for each pull request.
- Yes
Reviews
- Pre-Review Tools
Assists in polishing changes before review, showing diffs, build and test results, and style checks.
- Yes
- Turn Tracking
Track who needs to take the next action on a pull request.
- Yes
- Notifications
Companion Chrome extension that notifies you when your action is needed and see your review queue.
- Yes
- Merge Functionality
Changes are submitted and committed within Critique itself.
- Yes
- Keyboard Shortcuts
Navigation speed via amazing keyboard shortcuts.
- Yes
- Comment History Table
View analysis and history and comments of the PR in a tabular format that makes it much easier to understand the progress of a PR with multiple rounds of code
- IDE Integration
Integration with code editors.
- Issue Tracker Integration
Integration with issue/bug tracking software.
- Yes
- Linkification of Code & Comments
Auto linkification of both code and comments.
- Anonymized Reviews
Code reviews can also be anonymized, where the code author can be kept anonymous from the reviewer.
Diffs
- Revision History
Snapshots code when reviews are submitted and allow comparison between any two revisions.
- Yes
- Diff from Last Review
Pick up where you left off and only view changes since you last reviewed the files.
- Yes
- Side by Side Diff
Ability to compare two versions of a file side-by-side.
- Yes
- Unified Diff
Ability to compare two versions of a file in a single pane.
- Yes
- Syntax Highlighting
Diffing enhanced with syntax highlighting
- Yes
- Intraline Diffing
Highlight partial changes to an individual line of code.
- Yes
- Ignores Whitespace
Ignore whitespace changes to simplify the diff.
- Yes
- Cross References
- Move Detection
Detect code that moved to simplify the review process.
Comments
- Blocking & Non-Blocking Comments
Identify blocking issues that prevent pull request merging until resolved, or provide informational feedback and suggestions.
- Yes
- Comment Anywhere
Comment on any file and any line, with no restrictions.
- Yes
- Context Maintained
Comments intelligently maintain context/position as code evolves, ensuring they are always relevant.
- Yes
- Anyone Can Comment
Anyone can comment on a change and there are features to track review progress and resolve comments.
- Yes
- "Please Fix"
Reviewers have the option to click “Please fix” on an analysis generated comment as a signal that the author should fix the issue.
- Consistent Terminology
Social adoption of consistent terminology/tagging of comments (eg: optional, fyi, nit, etc.)
- Yes
- Discussion Resolution Flow
Guide individual discussions to a satisfactory resolution, verified by all necessary participants.
- Yes
- Discussion Assignment
Assign discussions to the responsible participant to ensure accountability.
- Yes
Other
- AI Tools
Helpful AI tools to aid your code review process.
- Beta
- GitHub Integration
Full two-way data sync'ing of pull requests, reviews, comments, reactions and more.
- Yes
- Live Team Status
See who's online and what pull requests your teammates are currently working on.
- Yes
- Elegant Design
We labor over the UX so you don’t have to. CodePeer helps you get stuff done and gets out of the way.
- Yes
- Light and Dark Mode
Choose between light and dark mode to manage your eye strain.
- Yes
- Ridiculously Fast
Heavily optimized for performance, because milliseconds matter.
- Yes
Feature comparison
Review Dashboard
Feature | Critique | CodePeer |
---|---|---|
Review Dashboard Dashboard showcasing all pull requests your involved in. | Yes | Yes |
Attention Set List of pull requests currently waiting on you. | Yes | Yes |
Who's Turn to Act Showcases who a pull request is waiting on. | Yes | Yes |
Pull Requests Go Green When pull requests reached an approved state, the status turns green and you rejoice. | Yes | Yes |
Time Estimates View estimates for how long a review should take and plan your schedule accordingly. | Yes | |
Snooze Snooze pull requests you want to tackle later to keep your inbox actionable. | Yes | |
Remaining Items Quickly see a breakdown of the work you have remaining (discussions, files, and lines of code to review) for each pull request. | Yes |
Reviews
Feature | Critique | CodePeer |
---|---|---|
Pre-Review Tools Assists in polishing changes before review, showing diffs, build and test results, and style checks. | Yes | Yes |
Turn Tracking Track who needs to take the next action on a pull request. | Yes | Yes |
Notifications Companion Chrome extension that notifies you when your action is needed and see your review queue. | Yes | Yes |
Merge Functionality Changes are submitted and committed within Critique itself. | Yes | Yes |
Keyboard Shortcuts Navigation speed via amazing keyboard shortcuts. | Yes | Yes |
Comment History Table View analysis and history and comments of the PR in a tabular format that makes it much easier to understand the progress of a PR with multiple rounds of code | Yes | |
IDE Integration Integration with code editors. | Yes | |
Issue Tracker Integration Integration with issue/bug tracking software. | Yes | Yes |
Linkification of Code & Comments Auto linkification of both code and comments. | Yes | |
Anonymized Reviews Code reviews can also be anonymized, where the code author can be kept anonymous from the reviewer. | Yes |
Diffs
Feature | Critique | CodePeer |
---|---|---|
Revision History Snapshots code when reviews are submitted and allow comparison between any two revisions. | Yes | Yes |
Diff from Last Review Pick up where you left off and only view changes since you last reviewed the files. | Yes | Yes |
Side by Side Diff Ability to compare two versions of a file side-by-side. | Yes | Yes |
Unified Diff Ability to compare two versions of a file in a single pane. | Yes | |
Syntax Highlighting Diffing enhanced with syntax highlighting | Yes | Yes |
Intraline Diffing Highlight partial changes to an individual line of code. | Yes | Yes |
Ignores Whitespace Ignore whitespace changes to simplify the diff. | Yes | Yes |
Cross References | Yes | |
Move Detection Detect code that moved to simplify the review process. | Yes |
Comments
Feature | Critique | CodePeer |
---|---|---|
Blocking & Non-Blocking Comments Identify blocking issues that prevent pull request merging until resolved, or provide informational feedback and suggestions. | Yes | Yes |
Comment Anywhere Comment on any file and any line, with no restrictions. | Yes | Yes |
Context Maintained Comments intelligently maintain context/position as code evolves, ensuring they are always relevant. | Yes | Yes |
Anyone Can Comment Anyone can comment on a change and there are features to track review progress and resolve comments. | Yes | Yes |
"Please Fix" Reviewers have the option to click “Please fix” on an analysis generated comment as a signal that the author should fix the issue. | Yes | |
Consistent Terminology Social adoption of consistent terminology/tagging of comments (eg: optional, fyi, nit, etc.) | Yes | Yes |
Discussion Resolution Flow Guide individual discussions to a satisfactory resolution, verified by all necessary participants. | Yes | |
Discussion Assignment Assign discussions to the responsible participant to ensure accountability. | Yes |
Other
Feature | Critique | CodePeer |
---|---|---|
AI Tools Helpful AI tools to aid your code review process. | Yes | Beta |
GitHub Integration Full two-way data sync'ing of pull requests, reviews, comments, reactions and more. | Yes | |
Live Team Status See who's online and what pull requests your teammates are currently working on. | Yes | |
Elegant Design We labor over the UX so you don’t have to. CodePeer helps you get stuff done and gets out of the way. | Yes | |
Light and Dark Mode Choose between light and dark mode to manage your eye strain. | Yes | |
Ridiculously Fast Heavily optimized for performance, because milliseconds matter. | Yes |